Neither party has acknowledged the situation, sources report, though both are “very aware”
PINEWOOD ESTATES—A local man opened what family sources have confirmed was the exact same Christmas gift exchange item he gave his brother-in-law twelve months ago, and reportedly said nothing. The incident occurred at approximately 10:47 AM during the Henderson family’s annual Christmas morning gathering.
“He unwrapped it, looked at it for about three seconds too long, and then said ‘Oh nice, thanks,'” reported one witness who requested anonymity because she is married to the gift-giver. “Then he set it down and immediately asked if anyone wanted more coffee.”
Gift Exchange Silence Speaks Volumes
The item in question—a premium beard grooming kit that retails for approximately $34.99—was originally purchased by the recipient, Kevin Henderson, 41, for his brother-in-law Mark Tillman, 38, during last year’s Christmas gift exchange. Tillman apparently stored it in his garage for eleven months before rewrapping it.
“The tag still had that little string on it from when I hung it on the tree last year,” Henderson reportedly told his wife later. “I recognized the string. I tied a specific knot. That was my knot.”
However, Henderson made no public comment during the gift exchange itself. Instead, he smiled, nodded, and complimented the wrapping paper.
A Pattern Emerges
Family members have begun reviewing previous years’ Christmas gift exchange records. Additionally, questions have emerged about a waffle maker that has reportedly appeared at three consecutive family gatherings.
“I’m starting to think there are maybe four actual gifts in circulation,” said Henderson’s cousin, speaking on background. “We’re just passing them around. Consequently, nobody wants to be the one to say anything because then we’d all have to start actually shopping.”
Neither Henderson nor Tillman responded to requests for comment. However, both have reportedly already discussed which family member will receive the beard kit next year.
Developing.
About the Author
